Spotify Wrapped... in Losses?

The first search engine for leads

Leadsforge is the very first search engine for leads. With a chat-like, easy interface, getting new leads is as easy as texting a friend! Just describe your ideal customer in the chat - industry, role, location, or other specific criteria - and our AI-powered search engine will instantly find and verify the best leads for you. No more guesswork, just results. Your lead lists will be ready in minutes!

Sign & get 100 credits

Table of Contents

• The birth of Spotify

• Business Model: Great for Users, Brutal for the Bottom Line

• Growth Strategies & Controversies

• Competitive Landscape

• Future Challenges & Opportunities

• Conclusion: The Path to Profitability

• Lessons For Entrepreneurs

The Birth Of Spotify

Spotify didn’t set out to sell music. It set out to kill piracy.

In 2006, Daniel Ek and Martin Lorentzon launched Spotify from Stockholm with a simple question: What if people didn’t have to steal music to enjoy it? Their vision was clear—build a legal alternative to Napster that didn’t feel like a compromise.

They understood something the rest of the industry missed: people didn’t want to own music. They just wanted instant access—free, fast, and frictionless.

But getting there wasn’t easy.

Music labels weren’t thrilled about the idea of free streaming. To get them on board, Spotify offered a deal—70% of revenue would go to rights holders, plus equity in the company. That opened doors.

On the tech side, they used a peer-to-peer caching system to reduce buffering—crucial in a world of slow internet speeds. And instead of pushing subscriptions from day one, they introduced a freemium model: free with ads, or pay to upgrade. Simple, yet powerful.

Business Model: Great for Users, Brutal for the Bottom Line

Spotify built a product that users love—intuitive design, personalized playlists, and access to millions of tracks on demand. But behind that seamless experience is a business model that’s hard to sustain.

It’s not that Spotify doesn’t make money. It does. The issue is what happens to that money once it comes in. Here’s a simple breakdown

How Spotify Makes Money

Spotify runs on two primary revenue streams:

1. Subscriptions

   • Makes up 86% of total revenue

   • Standard plan priced at $10.99/month (post-2023 hike)

   • Covers individual, family, and student plans

2. Advertising

   • Accounts for the remaining 14%

   • Earned through audio and video ads, podcast sponsorships, and programmatic ad placements

   • Mostly driven by the free-tier users

So far, so good, right? But revenue is only one side of the story.

So, What’s the Problem?

Spotify doesn’t own the music—it rents it.

Every time you hit play, Spotify pays a licensing fee to rights holders, which includes record labels, publishers, and artists. On average, that amounts to $0.003–$0.005 per stream. So:

• 1 million streams = $3,000–$5,000, split between the label and the artist

• Many mid-level artists still earn less than $50/month, fueling the long-standing debate over fair payouts

But the real pinch? Roughly 70% of Spotify’s total revenue goes to rights holders. That leaves just 30% to cover everything else—tech, operations, marketing, R&D, and more.

And it gets worse with scale. The more Spotify grows, the more it streams. The more it streams, the more it pays out. So growth doesn't mean higher profit—it just means higher costs.

Why Spotify Can’t Cut Costs

Spotify is trapped in a tight space with little wiggle room. Here’s why:

1. Label Power

   • Three companies—Universal, Sony, and Warner—control nearly 70% of the global music catalog

   • They set the terms, and Spotify has no choice but to comply

   • Any pushback can mean serious consequences—like Taylor Swift pulling her catalog in 2014 over royalty disputes

2. Competitive Pricing

   • Apple Music and Amazon Music offer the same monthly plans at $10.99

   • YouTube Music goes a step further with a fully free, ad-supported tier

   • Spotify can't raise prices too aggressively without risking user churn

A. Podcasts: The $1 Billion Gamble

To escape the royalty trap, Spotify’s bet was simple: own more of the content people are listening to. Between 2019 and 2022, it went on a podcast shopping spree—acquiring platforms and shows to shift listener time away from licensed music.

1. Key acquisitions:

   • Anchor – podcast creation platform (~$140M)

   • Gimlet Media (~$230M)

   • The Ringer – sports and culture podcast network (~$196M)

2. Exclusive deals:

   • Joe Rogan – $200M+ deal, now pulling in over 190M monthly downloads

   • Obamas, Meghan Markle – big names, but disappointing returns (Markle’s show was canceled in 2023)

The result?
Podcasts now account for ~20% of all listening time on Spotify. But despite spending over $1 billion, the returns remain unclear. By 2023, Spotify laid off staff at both Gimlet and Anchor. The pivot was bold—but profitability? Still questionable.

B. Algorithmic Control & the “Fake Artists” Controversy

Spotify’s personalization engine—Discover Weekly, Release Radar, and algorithmic playlists—drives around 30% of total streams. But not without some raised eyebrows.

1. Controversy 1: "Fake Artists"
   Spotify was accused of promoting royalty-free music (from sources like Epidemic Sound) under fake artist names. The idea? Cut down on royalty payments while filling playlists with ambient or instrumental music.

2. Controversy 2: Payola
   There have been industry claims that record labels pay for placement in major playlists. Spotify denies this, but the lack of transparency keeps the topic alive.

The algorithm works—for users. But who benefits behind the scenes is still debated.

C. Global Expansion Tactics

Spotify’s international growth playbook is focused on hyper-local relevance and smart distribution:

1. Localized playlists: Tailored to regional tastes—“Bollywood Butter”, “K-Pop Daebak”, and more

2. Telecom partnerships: Bundled Spotify Premium with carriers like Vodafone for wider access

3. Hardware integrations: Built into platforms like Tesla, Sonos, and gaming consoles to stay embedded in daily life

Spotify didn’t just go global—it felt local. And that made all the difference in markets where music tastes vary wildly.

Competitive Landscape

Spotify might be the biggest player in the streaming world, but it's far from alone. The space is crowded with heavyweights—each with their own angle, bundled perks, or hardware advantage.

Here are some other major players with their numbers:

How Spotify Holds Its Ground

Even with deep-pocketed rivals, Spotify leads the market—and it’s not by accident.

1. Network Effects

• Over 3 billion playlists created by users

• Personal sharing and playlist culture make Spotify feel less like a service and more like a habit

2. Data Moat

• Spotify’s AI recommendation engine is a core strength

• Features like Discover Weekly, Blend, and Spotify Wrapped turn listening data into addictively personal experiences

While others rely on bundling or ecosystems, Spotify wins by making music discovery feel uniquely yours. And that, so far, has kept users loyal.

Future Challenges & Opportunities

The company has to navigate new threats, from rising royalty costs to the rise of AI-generated music. At the same time, fresh opportunities are opening up in areas like audiobooks, ad tech, and fan monetization. The question now isn’t whether Spotify will grow—it’s whether it can grow profitably. Here’s what’s coming next:

Challenges Ahead

1. Label Renegotiations (2025): Spotify’s deals with major labels are up for renewal. If royalty rates increase, margins could shrink even further—putting more pressure on an already tight model.

2. AI Disruption: The rise of synthetic music—like AI-generated Drake tracks—poses a double-edged threat. It could flood the platform with content while sidestepping traditional royalty structures.

3. Regulation (EU DMA): Under the EU’s Digital Markets Act, Apple may be forced to lower App Store fees (currently 30% on iOS subscriptions). While this could benefit Spotify, it also adds regulatory uncertainty to its roadmap.

Opportunities on the Horizon

1. Audiobooks: Launched in 2023, Spotify is testing the waters in the audiobook space. If it plays out like podcasts, it could create another stream of high-engagement, owned content.

2. Advanced Ad Tech: The Spotify Audience Network is pushing targeted podcast ads across its ecosystem. This could help boost ad revenue—especially from the free-tier user base.

3. Superfan Monetization: Spotify is exploring new ways for artists to earn—think tipping, exclusive content, and even NFT-based collectibles. Done right, this could deepen artist loyalty and diversify revenue.

Conclusion: The Path to Profitability

The product is sticky, the brand is global, and user growth is still strong. But scale alone won’t fix the economics. For Spotify, the road to profit depends on shifting from rented content to owned ecosystems. However, The big question is…

Can Spotify Succeed?

Yes, if:

• Diversification Pays Off: Investments in podcasts, audiobooks, and AI-driven content reduce reliance on traditional music royalties.​

• Enhanced Monetization: Advanced ad technologies and innovative monetization strategies, such as artist tipping and exclusive content, boost margins.

No, if:

• Increased Royalty Demands: Major labels leverage their power to demand higher payouts during renegotiations.​

• Aggressive Competition: Competitors like Apple and YouTube undercut Spotify on price or bundle superior offerings.

By the Numbers (Q4 2024)

• Monthly Active Users (MAUs): 675 million (+12% YoY)

• Premium Subscribers: 263 million (+11% YoY) ​

• Total Revenue: €4.2 billion (+16% YoY)

• Operating Income: €477 million (compared to a loss of €75 million in Q4 2023)

These figures indicate a positive trajectory, with Spotify achieving its first full year of profitability in 2024. However, sustaining this momentum requires strategic innovation and careful navigation of industry challenges

Final Takeaway

Spotify's challenge is to evolve beyond being merely a music streaming platform. Without innovation and diversification, it risks becoming the Netflix of audio—widely used but struggling with thin margins. To secure long-term profitability, Spotify must own more of its content ecosystem and explore new revenue streams.​

Lessons For Entrepreneurs

Start learning AI in 2025

Keeping up with AI is hard – we get it!

That’s why over 1M professionals read Superhuman AI to stay ahead.

• Get daily AI news, tools, and tutorials

• Learn new AI skills you can use at work in 3 mins a day

• Become 10X more productive

Sign up and start mastering AI

About Think Tank
_______________________________________

Think Tank is a bi-weekly newsletter that simplifies business case studies into engaging, story-driven insights. It’s designed for entrepreneurs, professionals, and curious minds who want real, actionable takeaways without the fluff.